Read Mode
Time And Work (Pipes)
Two pipes A and B can fill a cistern in 20 and 30 minutes respectively, and a third pipe C can empty it in 40 minutes. How long will it take to fill the cistern if all three pipes are opened at the same time?
Explanation and memory cue
Pipe A fills 1/20 of the cistern per minute, pipe B fills 1/30 per minute, and pipe C empties 1/40 per minute. Net fill rate = 1/20 + 1/30 - 1/40 = (6/120) + (4/120) - (3/120) = 7/120 per minute. Time to fill = 1 / (7/120) = 120/7 = 17 1/7 minutes. However, the calculation shows 17 1/7 minutes, which matches option C, so the original answer is correct. Rechecking the calculation: 1/20=0.05, 1/30=0.0333, 1/40=0.025; net=0.05+0.0333-0.025=0.0583; time=1/0.0583=17.14 minutes, which is 17 1/7 minutes. Therefore, the original correct answer C is correct. The initial confusion was in the explanation. The correct answer is C.