Read Mode
Speed, Time and Distance
Three towns X, Y, and Z are on a river which flows uniformly. Y is equidistant from X and Z. If a boatman rows from X to Y and back in 10 hours and from X to Z in 4 hours downstream, find the ratio of the speed of the boatman in still water to the speed of the current.
Correct answer: B
Explanation and memory cue
Let the speed of the boat in still water be b and the speed of the current be c. Let the distance between X and Y be d. Since Y is equidistant from X and Z, distance XZ = 2d. Time taken from X to Y and back is 10 hours: (d/(b-c)) + (d/(b+c)) = 10 Time taken from X to Z is 4 hours: 2d/(b-c) = 4 From the second equation, d = 2(b-c). Substitute d in the first equation: (2(b-c)/(b-c)) + (2(b-c)/(b+c)) = 10 => 2 + 2(b-c)/(b+c) = 10 => 2(b-c)/(b+c) = 8 => (b-c)/(b+c) = 4 This is not possible as the ratio must be less than 1. Re-examining the problem, the time from X to Z is 4 hours downstream, so speed downstream is (b+c), and time = distance/speed = 2d/(b+c) = 4. So, 2d/(b+c) = 4 => d = 2(b+c). Now substitute d in the first equation: (d/(b-c)) + (d/(b+c)) = 10 => (2(b+c)/(b-c)) + (2(b+c)/(b+c)) = 10 => 2(b+c)/(b-c) + 2 = 10 => 2(b+c)/(b-c) = 8 => (b+c)/(b-c) = 4 Let r = b/c. Then (r+1)/(r-1) = 4 => r+1 = 4r - 4 => 3r = 5 => r = 5/3 Therefore, the ratio of the speed of the boatman in still water to the speed of the current is 5:3.